ecoFibbing is a Skin Irritant

Nothing gets under my skin more than green washing… LITERALLY!  A few years ago when I made significant changes to my lifestyle, one area that I found extremely hard to navigate was the area of personal care products.  My bathroom countertop, cabinets, drawers, and every inch of ledge space in the shower was full of bottles.  Shampoo in three different scents, two types of conditioner, creamy body wash, gel body wash, bar soap,  2-in-1 shampoo, 10 different colors and fragrances of body lotion, 3 bottles of perfume, not to mention make-up, mouth wash, 3 tubes of toothpaste, floss, and on and on and on… complete insanity!

I had so much stuff that I put sorority girls to shame!

Why did I have so much stuff?  Because I had coupons! 

So a few minutes ago as I was searching for some information on an unrelated topic, I came to a website featuring articles about carcinogenic ingredients in our products and the need to be aware of what we “put on our largest organ, our skin”, and stay away from toxic ingredients, and yadda yadda yadda… I’m all happy… until I see a big’ol button that says…

“Click here for Safe & Healthy Products”

So I click… and click… and click… Oh, nice Product page… let’s check out the Personal Care category.

Greeted with…. “Recognizing the need for a viable solution to an overwhelming worldwide problem, XXX Personal Care products were designed without potentially harmful ingredients.”

I click on More Info & Ingredients under the Indulge Bubble Bath.

and…WHAM!   My heart starts racing and my skin starts crawling because it nothing but CRAP… and definitely harmful ingredients for our largest organ!

The lovely description states that it helps ease stiff muscles and tension with the botanical blend of hops extract and Chinese geranium.

But the ingredients:

Purified Water
Sodium C14-16 Olefin Sulfonate – produced by boiling petrochemicals with boiling sulfuric acid
Cocamidopropyl Hydroxysultaine – Causes eye stinging and redness, redness and burning of skin, toxicological properties have NOT been investigated
Sodium Isostearoyl Lactylate
Sodium C 12-15 Pareth-15 Sulfonate – reacting petrochemicals with sulfuric acid
Aromatic Fragrance - human immune system toxicant, skin toxicant,
Ammonium Chloride - Carcinogen, skin irritant, neurotoxin
Spirea Extract
Hops Extract
Matricaria Extract
Laurel Extract
Methylchloroisothiazolinone – human immune system toxicant, human skin toxicant, harmful by skin absorption, corrosion and burns to the eyes and skin, permanent irreversible eye damage, nitrosating agent
Methylisothiazolinone – neurotoxin, human immune system toxicant, skin toxicant, restricted use in Canada and Japan.

I don’t know about you, but the last thing I want to feed by skin during a 30-minute bubble bath is any of the above!

This is blatant green washing and it’s sad that it’s legal.

The bottom line – not all green, natural companies are authentic, genuine, and principle-centered.  Most of them seem to win the consumer’s heart by just carelessly throwing the words out in their fabulously looking marketing campaigns.

I think it’s about time we used our brains and made them win our hearts the old-fashioned way… with integrity, honesty, and a whole lot of hard work.

So… green, organic, natural companies better be walking the talk from beginning to end… and recycling too!

By the way,  I now have three simple bottles in my shower, a tiny make-up bag, and one tube of toothpaste!  Every single bottle, jar, container is 100% recyclable.

Ah, the joys of simplicity!

Organic – More than a Personal Choice

What’s the big deal about organics? As the daughter of a dairy farmer in the Midwest, my lifestyle choices have caused quite a stir among family and friends.  They just don’t quite understand what is at stake, but I love sharing and learning and educating and learning more.  Honestly I still consider myself an organic beginner.  I have so much to learn and the majority of my journey has been focused on learning about my dietary choices, the cleaning products I use, and the dozens of personal care products that cover every inch of my bathroom counter-space.  The most profound lesson:  my choices in each of these areas directly impacts my environment, but more importantly I also impact the environment for all other living creatures.  So I have a choice – will I positively or negatively impact the environment?  That’s a significant question with a very important answer.

Choosing to wisely spend my $$ on products that are certified organic benefits more than just me.  Each decision to choose greener, specifically certified organic, alternatives supports a sustainable means of producing products.  The 6-second decision between a certified organic moisturizer and a typical moisturizer holds consequences that are quite eye-opening.  Once I understood, I no longer had a decision to make.  The decision was made for me.

What exactly does certified organic mean?

Organic agriculture is quite simply farming without the use of synthetic chemicals and pesticides.  Yes, it can be done even in the 21st Century!   Therefore, eliminating chemical application to crops, eliminates them from the soil, water contamination, food contamination, as well as the negative (an unknown) affects on our health and the health of other living organisms as a result of the chemical exposure.

My 6-second purchasing decision directly affects my health and indirectly affects the health of the fish in the streams, the birds in the trees, and my relatives a few hours away.

It’s natural, pure, AND organic!

“Cosmetics products and ingredients are not subject to FDA premarket approval authority, with the exception of color additives… [the] FDA cannot require companies to do safety testing of their cosmetics before marketing.” (FDA website).

Long story short, the dozens of lotions and potions that have consumed every inch of counter space in our bathrooms are concoctions of thousands of chemicals that have not been tested for safety.  Just that thought alone is enough to make my skin tingle!  All along we’ve assumed that someone somewhere had a high paying job making sure that our stuff was safe.  Not so true after all.

Not to mention the following excerpts from Healthy Child, Healthy World:

•    The average American uses about 10–15 personal care products daily.  I counted more than that for myself… remember this involved everything that goes on the skin.  Soap when washing your hands, dish soap, lotion, lip moisturizers, antibacterial gels, cleansers, make-up, toothpaste, mouthwash, and so on.

•    The FDA approves an average of seven new chemicals every day, and 80 percent are approved in three weeks or less, with or without safety tests.
Wow!  Less than three weeks of testing… are you kidding me?

•    Industrial chemicals are the basic ingredients of personal care products that contain carcinogens, pesticides, reproductive toxins, endocrine disruptors, plasticizers, degreasers, and surfactants.

So, in a self-regulated industry where terms like ‘organic’ and  ‘all natural’ appear on products contaminated with toxins like 1,4-Dioxane, how are consumers to navigate the so-called-’Green’ cosmetics industry and avoid green washed products?

The most important first step is knowing the difference between the following: natural, naturally-derived, organic, certified organic.

Natural: A natural material that is harvested and processed without chemical reaction. Therefore, for a product to claim to be “all natural”, each and every ingredient would have to exist in nature the exact same way as it was used to make the final product.  An example would be Aloe.  Aloe is extracted from the plant and applied to the skin without processing.

Naturally-derived: Since the cosmetic & personal care industry is not regulated, often times, they claim that “naturally-derived” ingredients are natural. For example, the ingredient Cocamide DEA, which is a known human immune system toxicant as defined by the National Library of Medicine, is derived from coconuts. It is used in most cleansers and soaps. Therefore, naturally-derived is not natural at all. It is a synthetic that involved a chemical process regardless of the source. The danger of using a naturally-derived/synthetic ingredient is that the processing aids and impurities are linked to asthma, learning disabilities, infertility, birth defects, and cancer.

Another fun example is vodka.  Vodka is “naturally-derived” from potatoes.  Would you want to give your child vodka?  Legally they could say it’s natural!

Organic: Organic refers to a system of ecological farm management that promotes biodiversity, enhances soil fertility, prevents soil erosion, protects groundwater, conserves energy, and protects our next generation. Organic agriculture prohibits genetic engineering, pesticides synthetic fertilizers, antibiotics, and growth hormones. Many companies now claim to have “organic” products. Without the third-party certification, most likely the product has one or two organic ingredients. Again, this is all unregulated and a product does not have to have any organic ingredients to have the word “organic” in the title. For example, a shampoo can claim to be organic with lavender. The product is most likely 70% water, which has been infused with organic lavender tea bags. In this case, although water in not included in a certified organic product, this shampoo label may claim to be made with 70% organic ingredients. This is a huge problem and is currently legal.

Certified Organic: This is the consumer’s guarantee that they are not being greenwashed. It is a guarantee of authenticity and integrity that every ingredient stands up to the claims made by the manufacturer. The “certified organic” stamp should be visible on the label. The type of certification is also important. Currently the USDA (United States Department of Agriculture) and ACO (Australian Certified Organic) are the most stringent in the world. The products bearing these logos are edible and certified to food grade standards. Certified Organic products are minimally processed, naturally extracted, WITHOUT artificial ingredients, synthetic processes, synthetic preservatives, animal testing, and irradiation. Certified Organic Processors must: keep detailed written purchasing, production, and sales records (audit trail), develop stringent quality systems to maintain organic integrity of ingredients, ensure traceability of organic ingredients (from seed to consumer), maintain strict physical separation of ingredients to prevent contamination, undergo periodic on-site inspections (audits).

NOTE: There are various certifying agencies with their own rules and regulations.  The next few posts will contain such information.